Chief Justice of Pakistan Omar Ata Bandial said that the observation given in the judgment of the court is very important as such matters should be resolved in the Parliament instead of the reference. Should
The Attorney General took the position that the mandate of the people emerges collectively in the House and political parties legislate for the people in the House.
Justice Jamal Khan Mandokhel said that the right to vote belongs to the members of the Assembly and not to the party members. O brought.
To what extent is party discipline restricted? So the Attorney General replied that if the party is not being listened to then he can resign and after resigning he can go to the people again.
Justice Ejaz-ul-Ahsan said that while getting tickets, the candidates know when they cannot vote freely.
Does any member have the right to express a decision against the party? Justice Ijaz-ul-Ahsan said that the government can be overthrown by jumping in the second boat. Most democratic governments are formed with a lead of a few votes. The Can first ship be sunk in the second boat?
Justice Muneeb Akhtar said that if the leaps continue to be made then normal legislation cannot be enacted.
The Attorney General said that the issue is not just about the sword of 63A but the whole system is about to fail. I will not go into the question of stopping horse trading. This issue should be left to the Parliament.
Justice Muneeb Akhtar remarked that if everyone did as they wished, the political party would not become an institution but a mob and institutions would be destroyed by empowering individual personalities.
Justice Jamal Mandokhel asked whether floor crossing is allowed in other developed countries. Do you want to make the party leader the king of peace? The constitution has empowered the parliamentary party not the party leader and the overall opinion of the party is above the individual opinion.
Collective opinion is necessary for the stability of the political system Article 63A was added for
The Attorney General took the position that no one should be made a looter if he is not a king. Deviation from party policy should be disqualified for life. It is not a matter of conscience to join the opposition.